List hygiene7 min read

How fast do email lists decay? Facts and a clean-up routine

An illustration of an envelope with a green check mark on it

Short answer

At least 22.71% of an email list goes bad every year, according to ZeroBounce's report on emails it verified in 2022. Other published estimates run from roughly 15% to 30%, so treat all of them as planning numbers. Verify any list older than three months before a large send, and remove bounces after every send.

Key takeaways

  • ZeroBounce's report puts list decay at 22.71% or more per year. Other published estimates run from roughly 15% to 30%.
  • Amazon SES asks for a bounce rate below 5%, and Google asks for a spam rate below 0.30%. Old addresses can push both up.
  • Our rule of thumb: verify lists older than three months before a big send, and treat lists over 12 months old as cold.
  • Measure your own decay by comparing the bounce rate of your last send with older sends and by counting addresses that never open.

How fast does an email list go bad?

ZeroBounce's report on emails it verified in 2022 says that at least 22.71% of an email list goes bad every year. Other published estimates run from roughly 15% to 30% per year, and most come from verification vendors. Treat every figure as a planning number.

Here is the ZeroBounce figure in practice: a list of 10,000 addresses loses about 2,271 of them in twelve months. Your list can land above or below that. Further down, you will see how to measure your own rate.

Why do email addresses stop working?

Addresses stop working for ordinary reasons. ZeroBounce's report names people leaving jobs or switching to new addresses as the cause of the decay it measured. Three more general causes add to that.

  • Company changes: a business moves to another email provider or closes its domain, and the old mailboxes disappear.
  • Abandoned free mailboxes: people open a new address and stop checking the old one. The old address may still accept mail, but nobody reads it.
  • Typos at signup: a misspelled address never worked, so it counts as bad from day one.

What does an old list cost you?

Mail to dead addresses comes back as hard bounces. A hard bounce happens when an email goes to an address that does not exist. Amazon SES's documentation says to keep the bounce rate below 5%. At 5% or more, SES places the account under review. At 10% or more, SES might pause sending. SES counts hard bounces only.

Complaints add a second cost. Google's sender guidelines say to keep the spam rate shown in Postmaster Tools below 0.30%, and Google recommends staying below 0.10%. People who no longer remember signing up may report your mail as spam.

Yahoo's best practices tell senders to track hard bounces, soft bounces and inactive recipients, and to remove invalid recipients promptly. Over a year, all three groups grow. For scale: 5% of 10,000 sends is 500 hard bounces, while 22.71% of 10,000 addresses is 2,271 bad ones. Not every bad address ends as a hard bounce, so your count will differ.

What should you do at each list age?

ZeroBounce's report gives no re-verification interval, so the table below is a rule of thumb from our author team. It is not measured data. The older the list, the more you check before you send.

Rule of thumb by list age. A suggestion from our author team, not measured data.
List ageWhat to doWhy
Under 3 monthsSend as usual. Remove addresses that bounce.Few addresses have had time to change.
3 to 6 monthsVerify before a large send.Job changes and closed mailboxes have piled up since the last check.
6 to 12 monthsVerify, then send a small batch first. Read the bounce rate before you send the rest.The small batch shows your real bounce rate before it reaches everyone.
Over 12 monthsTreat the list as cold. Verify, ask people to reconfirm interest, and expect losses.On the ZeroBounce estimate, more than one in five addresses has gone bad by now.

How big is a small batch? A few hundred to a thousand addresses is enough to read a bounce rate. Compare that rate with the rate of your earlier sends. If it is clearly higher, clean more before you send the rest.

Verification shows which addresses can still receive mail. To learn who still wants your mail, ask for reconfirmation, especially on the oldest lists. If you did not collect the list yourself, cleaning does not fix the missing permission. A bought list is the clearest example.

How do you measure decay on your own list?

Compare the bounce rate of your last send with the rate of older sends to the same list. Bounce rate is bounced messages divided by messages sent, times 100, so 120 bounces on 8,000 sends is 1.5%. A rate that climbs from send to send shows the list is aging. Our guide to a good email bounce rate explains which levels to aim for.

  • Count the addresses that never open. Google's Postmaster Tools help says to consider unsubscribing recipients who don't open or read your messages.
  • List the addresses that have not interacted lately. Amazon SES's documentation advises purging addresses that haven't interacted with your emails recently.
  • Send a reconfirmation email to inactive subscribers. Yahoo's best practices suggest this for inactive recipients.
  • Verify a random sample of 500 or 1,000 addresses and count the share that come back invalid. That share gives you a rough decay estimate for the whole list.

Here is a worked example. You verify a random sample of 1,000 addresses from a list of 20,000, and 180 come back invalid. That is 18%, so about 3,600 addresses on the full list are likely invalid. A sample gives an estimate. A larger sample gives a steadier one.

What routine keeps a list fresh?

Five steps keep decay small: check addresses at signup, remove bounces after each send, retire inactive subscribers, re-verify before big sends, and write down what you removed. Work through them in this order.

  1. Check addresses at signup. Use confirmed (double) opt-in, which Yahoo's best practices recommend. A mistyped address usually never confirms, so it stays off the list.
  2. Remove hard bounces after every send. A hard bounce means the address does not exist.
  3. Retire inactive subscribers. Pick a window, for example six months without opens or clicks, send one reconfirmation email, and remove everyone who does not answer.
  4. Re-verify before big sends. Check any list or segment older than three months, then work through our list cleaning checklist.
  5. Write down the result. Record the date and the share of addresses you removed. After two or three rounds you have your own decay rate and can plan with it.

Frequently asked questions

How much of an email list goes bad each year?

At least 22.71%, according to ZeroBounce's report on emails it verified in 2022. Other published estimates run from roughly 15% to 30% per year, and most come from verification vendors. Use these numbers for planning, then measure your own list to find your rate.

How often should I clean my email list?

Verify any list older than three months before a large send, and remove hard bounces after every send. This is a rule of thumb from our author team. ZeroBounce's report gives no re-verification interval, and the right pace depends on how fast your own list decays.

Can I still mail a list that is over a year old?

Only if the people on it agreed to get your mail. Verify the list, ask people to reconfirm interest, send a small batch first and expect losses. Verification shows which addresses can receive mail. It cannot make a list without permission acceptable.

Which bounce rate shows that my list has gone stale?

Amazon SES's documentation says to keep the bounce rate below 5%. At 5% SES reviews the account, and at 10% it might pause sending. Treat those as upper limits. A rate that rises over several sends is the earlier warning.

Should I remove subscribers who never open my emails?

Google, Amazon SES and Yahoo all point that way. Google's Postmaster Tools help says to consider unsubscribing recipients who don't open, SES advises purging addresses that haven't interacted, and Yahoo suggests reconfirmation emails for inactive subscribers. Ask first, then remove those who do not answer.

Sources

  1. ZeroBounce report on email database decay
  2. Amazon SES: reputation metrics
  3. Yahoo: sender best practices
  4. Google Postmaster Tools help
  5. Google: email sender guidelines

Share this post

Clean your list before you send

Upload it, see every address's result and reason, download the clean part.

Start free
How fast do email lists decay? Facts and a clean-up routine